Your To-Do List is a Lie (And It's Making you a Worse Teacher)

In partnership with

It starts innocently enough. A quick mental note here, a scribbled sticky note there. Then, like a particularly enthusiastic slime mold, your to-do list grows. You cross off one item, and three more appear, hydra-like, demanding attention. Before you know it, you’re drowning in a sea of “should-dos” before the first bell even rings. This isn’t a personal failing; it’s the default setting for teaching, where the demands can feel as endless as a middle schooler’s TikTok feed.

If you’ve ever slumped into your chair at the end of the day, feeling utterly depleted despite having worked non-stop, this one’s for you. The problem isn’t you, your work ethic, or even your caffeine intake. The problem is the list itself. It's time we stopped letting the list be the boss and started taking back control.

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉️ How Growing Up Changes the Way We Hear, and Feel, Music

👉️ Ask kids this basic question to instantly make them more cooperative — the answer doesn't matter

👉️ We’re all doomed if English literature students can’t read books

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor:

Smart leaders don’t write books alone.

You built your business with a team. Your book should be no different.

Author.Inc helps founders and executives turn their ideas into world-class books that build revenue, reputation, and reach.

Their team – the same people behind projects with Tim Ferriss and Codie Sanchez – knows how to turn your expertise into something that moves markets.

Schedule a complimentary 15-minute call with Author.Inc’s co-founder to map out your Book Blueprint to identify your audience, angles, and ROI.

Do this before you commit a cent, or sentence. If it’s a go, they’ll show you how to write and publish it at a world-class level. 

If it’s a wait, you just avoided wasting time and money.

Get Your Free Book Blueprint.

And now, back to our regular scheduled program 👇️ 

The Great Wall Of Should

Your to-do list isn't just a collection of tasks; it’s a living, breathing entity with a penchant for gaslighting. It whispers sweet nothings like, “You really should color-code those binders for next year,” right after you’ve spent six hours grading essays. We treat every item on this ever-expanding scroll with the same urgency, from the earth-shattering (prepare students for exams) to the utterly trivial (organize the glitter shelf). This creates a psychological bottleneck, leading to decision fatigue before you've even had your second cup of coffee.

The relentless pressure to do it all, perfectly, is a trap. It turns every workday into an unwinnable game where the goalposts keep moving, and the score is always "not enough." This isn't just about efficiency; it's about sanity. When everything is a priority, absolutely nothing is. And that's no way to teach, or to live.

Taming the Paper Tiger with the ‘1-3-5’ Rule

Alright, let's get tactical. Instead of letting your to-do list boss you around like a substitute teacher on a sugar rush, we're going to put it in its place with the "1-3-5 Rule." This isn't another complicated system to learn; it's a simple filter to apply daily, a secret handshake with your schedule that says, "This is what 'done' looks like today."

On any given day, commit to tackling: 1 Big Thing, 3 Medium Things, and 5 Small Things. Your "Big Thing" is the non-negotiable, high-impact task that moves the needle—grading those midterms, planning the next unit, or finally tackling that curriculum meeting agenda. Your "Medium Things" are important but less immediate—prepping that lab, calling a couple of parents, or sending out the weekly newsletter. The "Small Things" are your quick wins—emailing a colleague, tidying your desk, watering the classroom plant, or putting up that new student art. This isn't about doing more; it's about doing the right amount of the right things so you can actually feel a sense of completion.

The Power of the 'Not-To-Do' List

Here’s a radical thought: the most effective teachers aren't necessarily the ones who do the most; they're the ones who strategically don't do the things that don't truly matter. Enter the "Not-To-Do" list, your new best friend in the quest for sanity. This isn't about slacking off; it's about fierce prioritization and ruthless efficiency, the kind that makes your energy last longer than a student's attention span on a Friday afternoon.

Think about it. Do you really need to create a brand-new, Pinterest-perfect anchor chart when last year's is 90% fine and a quick refresh will suffice? Does that email really need to be answered after 5 PM, or can it wait until tomorrow morning? Start identifying those time-sucking, energy-draining tasks that offer minimal returns and bravely put them on your "Not-To-Do" list. This isn't just about saving time; it's about reclaiming your mental space from the tyranny of the trivial.

You Are Not a Productivity Robot

Let's get one thing straight: your worth as an educator is not, repeat, not measured by the sheer volume of tasks you cross off a never-ending list. It's measured in the "aha!" moments in your classroom, the connections you forge with your students, the quiet victories, and the simple fact that you showed up, again, for another round. The to-do list is a tool, a guide, a sometimes-helpful reminder—it is absolutely not a report card on your value as a human being or as a professional.

A "good" day isn't one where your list is miraculously empty (because, let's be real, when does that ever happen?). A good day is one where you know you tackled the right things, the things that truly moved the needle for your students and for your own well-being. It's about prioritizing impact over pure activity, and remembering that sometimes, doing less, but doing it with intention and presence, is the most productive thing you can do.

The Bell Doesn't Dismiss You, You Dismiss You

The final bell rings for your students, but the mental bell for teachers often keeps clanging into the evening. Remember, that to-do list? It’s not going anywhere. It will patiently wait for you, probably with a few new items added by morning. The real victory isn't clearing the list; it's clearing your head and feeling a sense of quiet accomplishment at the end of the school day.

Give yourself the same grace you extend to your students. You are doing enough, and often, more than enough. You handled your 1 Big Thing, your 3 Medium Things, and your 5 Small Things. That's a day well-spent. So, when it's time, turn off the lights, close your door, and go home. Your well-being is the ultimate item on your "to-do" list.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.