You're Not The Friend, You're The Forge

In partnership with

Somewhere in the back-to-school PD — between the trust-fall icebreaker and the moment everyone got their lanyard — nobody stood up and said the quiet part out loud: a real chunk of this job is being disliked by the exact people you're trying to help. There's no slide for that. And it stings every single time, no matter how many years deep you are.

🔈️ But first, this week’s sponsor might help you get up to snuff on a skill that you always wanted to but never had time during the year for!

Trade Real-World Events. Get $10 Free.

Start trading real-world events. With Kalshi, you can trade on things you already follow: inflation, elections, sports, and more. It’s simple: buy “Yes” or “No” shares on what you think will happen, and earn returns if you’re right.

To get you started, we’re giving you a free $10. Use it to explore the platform, test your instincts, and see how prediction markets work in real time.

Join thousands already trading the news and putting their knowledge to work.

Claim your $10 and start trading now.

Put $10 to Work

_{Trade responsibly.}

And now back to making you an even better teacher. ⬇️ 

Noteworthy News

The Part the Lanyard Didn't Warn You About

The orientation covered the fire drill procedure, the photocopier code, and roughly forty acronyms. What it skipped was the afternoon in October when a twelve-year-old decides you are personally responsible for every injustice in their life and announces it with the conviction of a courtroom closing argument. The eye-roll. The muttered "this is SO unfair." The kid who quietly casts you as the villain of their school year and commits to the role.

Here's why it lands so hard: it only hurts because the caring is real. The "grow a thick skin" advice always arrives with the best intentions and the emotional resonance of a parking ticket. If teaching were just a job, "they don't like me" would slide right off. But nobody grades essays at 9 p.m. for a paycheck alone. The people most rattled by a student's disapproval are usually the ones who got into this precisely because they wanted to matter to kids — which is exactly why the disapproval finds the nerve.

So no, you're not being dramatic, and you don't need to toughen up in the cardboard-cutout sense. The ache is information. It means you showed up as a whole person, which is the only way anyone has ever done this job well.

You Were Never Hired to Be Liked

Here's the reframe worth taping to the desk where the inspirational cat poster used to be: the job was never to be liked. The job is to take small, unfinished humans and help them become bigger, more capable, more decent ones. That's the whole mission. And the shaping — the molding, the holding firm when folding would be so much easier — is frequently the exact thing that makes them mad at you in the moment.

This is the part that trips up good teachers, because it feels backwards. Surely if you're doing it right, they'd appreciate it? Sometimes, eventually, sure. But in real time, the kid who isn't allowed to coast, copy, or quit is rarely thrilled about it. Being disliked isn't a sign you're failing the mission. Sometimes it's proof you're doing it.

Tough skin, then, isn't a frozen heart and it isn't caring less. It's caring enough to be unpopular on purpose. It's choosing the version of the kid who exists in June over the version who's annoyed at you on Tuesday. You're not the friend who tells them what they want to hear. You're the forge — and forges, by design, run a little hot

The 15-Minute Honest Year-End Audit

When the "do they even like me?" spiral hits — and it tends to hit hardest right as the year winds down — resist the urge to journal your feelings into the void. The void has heard enough. Instead, run a short, deliberately unsentimental review. Five questions, fifteen minutes, zero budget, and a strict no-toxic-positivity policy. This isn't about feeling better. It's about seeing clearly.

Start with the only scorecard that counts: what can they actually DO now that they couldn't in September? Name real skills, not vibes. Then, where did you hold a hard line — and were you right to? If the answer is yes, file the resulting unpopularity under "job well done," not "personal failure." Next, the uncomfortable one: what did you do for approval that you should stop? The over-explaining, the negotiating, the rule quietly bent to be liked. Cut it next year.

Finally, the two that reveal your actual values. Which kid pushed you hardest — and did you stay steady anyway? The ones who fight the boundary most are usually testing whether it'll hold; your steadiness was the gift, even if it got a glare in return. And what's one thing you'd do the same even if it made every single kid mad? That answer is your value system, in writing. Protect it. Fifteen minutes, and a vague ache becomes a clear-eyed inventory.

A Friend Makes You Feel Good Now. A Teacher Makes You Capable Later.

A friend's job is to make someone feel good right now. A teacher's job is to make them capable later — and those two goals collide constantly. The most important adults in a kid's life are almost never the ones who never frustrated them. They're the ones who stayed steady, held the standard, and were still there the next morning with the same warmth and the same rules.

That combination — same warmth, same rules — is the whole trick. Tough skin isn't a frozen heart, and it isn't cynicism dressed up as wisdom. It's the boundary that lets you keep showing up with a soft mission intact: caring deeply about who these kids become while refusing to let their momentary opinion of you knock you off course.

You're not planting flowers that bloom by Friday. You're growing people, slowly, often without applause and almost always without a progress bar. The thank-you, if it comes at all, arrives years late — a message out of nowhere from a former student who finally gets it. You may never see it. Do the work anyway.

Steady Beats Liked

Being unpopular on purpose, in service of who a kid is becoming, is one of the least-thanked and most important things a teacher does all year. The glare you got for holding the line? That was the boundary working. Steadiness was the gift, even when it was received like a parking ticket.

So before you close the laptop for summer, run the five-question audit. Give it the honest fifteen minutes. And notice how many of the moments you'd quietly filed under "failure" were actually lines well held — proof, in retrospect, that you were doing the job exactly right..

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.