Why Taking A Sick Day Feels Like Commiting A Crime

There is a specific, cruel irony reserved only for educators: teaching is one of the only professions where taking a sick day requires more work than actually going to work. For an accountant, a sick day means an out-of-office email and a nap. For a teacher, it means waking up at 4:00 AM with a 102-degree fever, squinting at a laptop screen, and attempting to write instructions detailed enough for a stranger to manage 30 energetic souls without incident.

It is the "Sub Plan Paradox." The body screams for rest, but the brain screams about the logistical nightmare of being absent. The result? Teachers dragging themselves into school, pumped full of DayQuil and denial, infecting the staff room because the alternative—writing a 3-page manuscript on how to operate the SmartBoard—feels insurmountable. It’s time to validate the insanity of this dynamic and offer a way out that doesn't involve teaching through the flu.

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor

Unlock ChatGPT’s Full Power at Work

ChatGPT is transforming productivity, but most teams miss its true potential. Subscribe to Mindstream for free and access 5 expert-built resources packed with prompts, workflows, and practical strategies for 2025.

Whether you're crafting content, managing projects, or automating work, this kit helps you save time and get better results every week.

Get Your Free Resource Kit

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉️ Staff wellbeing 'crisis' forcing teachers out of schools, charity says

👉️ Stop asking 'How was school today?' To raise successful, mentally strong kids, ask these 7 questions instead

👉️ Concerns Raised As Teachers Increasingly Use AI To Write IEPs

The 4 AM Moral Dilemma

The internal monologue of a sick teacher is a study in guilt and catastrophe. It usually starts with a denial of symptoms ("It's just allergies... severe, shivering allergies") and ends with a vision of the classroom descending into Lord of the Flies chaos within fifteen minutes of the bell ringing. There is a pervasive feeling that stepping away, even for twenty-four hours, is an act of abandonment. This isn't just about workload; it's about a deep-seated "Martyr Complex" that suggests the educational ecosystem is so fragile it relies entirely on one person’s physical presence to function.

The expectation that a teacher must perform administrative acrobatics while physically incapacitated is, frankly, absurd. Imagine a pilot calling in sick and being told, "No problem, just write out a quick guide on how to land the plane for the passenger in 3B." Yet, year after year, teachers sit up in bed, bleary-eyed, crafting lesson plans that are more detailed than a nuclear launch code, just to ensure the students don't accidentally learn the wrong chapter of history.

This cycle of guilt and over-preparation leads to burnout and prolonged illness. By refusing to rest properly, the recovery time doubles, leading to... you guessed it, more sub plans. It is a hamster wheel of mucus and misery. The objective here isn't just to get a day off; it's to decouple the idea of "caring for students" from "destroying one's own well-being."

The "In Case of Emergency" Break Glass Protocol

The solution to the 4 AM panic is not better time management in the moment; it is strategic laziness prepared months in advance. Enter the "Evergreen Emergency Folder." This is not a folder for your planned curriculum. It is not for the unit you are currently teaching. This is a standalone, "Break Glass in Case of Emergency" survival kit. It sits on the desk (or in the Google Drive) physically labeled in bright red, ready to be deployed with a single text message to a department head or admin: "Use Day 1 in the Red Folder."

The secret to the Evergreen Folder is that the content must be timeless. It cannot rely on where the class was yesterday or where they need to be tomorrow. These are skills-based lessons, not content-based ones. By preparing three distinct days of generic, high-engagement plans at the start of the term—when energy is high and the immune system is strong—the friction of taking a sick day drops to zero. The goal is to make the sub plan process automatic, removing the decision-fatigue that plagues a feverish brain.

Three "Generic" Plans That Aren't Busy Work

So, what goes in the folder? "Read Chapter 4 silently" is a recipe for a riot, and "Word Search" is a recipe for mutiny. The best emergency plans are engaging enough to keep the room quiet but open-ended enough to work for any grade level or subject with minor tweaking.

1. The "Design a School Holiday" Project: Students are tasked with inventing a new national or school holiday. They must write a proposal including the holiday's historical significance (made up), the traditions, the food served, and design a commemorative stamp or flag. It requires writing, creativity, and persuasive argumentation. It kills 50 minutes easily, and the results are usually hilarious enough to read when you return.

2. Documentary Bingo: Pick a high-quality documentary relevant to the general subject (e.g., Our Planet for science, The Social Dilemma for social studies). Instead of a generic worksheet, provide a "Bingo" card with specific phrases, visual cues, or concepts to look for. It turns passive watching into active listening. The substitute just has to hit "play," and the students are gamified into paying attention.

3. The "Letter to My Future Self": A classic for a reason. Students write a letter to themselves to be opened at graduation or the end of the year. Provide prompts: "What are you worried about right now that won't matter then?", "What do you hope you've achieved?", "Who are your friends right now?" It’s quiet, introspective, and builds Social-Emotional Learning (SEL) skills without requiring a lesson on the board.

You Are a Human Being, Not a Load-Bearing Wall

Your Homework for Today: Nap

Here is the actionable step for this week: Before the next wave of seasonal crud sweeps through the hallways, build the Evergreen Folder. Spend one prep period creating three days of "break glass" lessons. Print them out. Put them in a red folder. Tell your department head where it is.

Then, the next time the thermometer spikes or the migraine hits, you can simply text "Red Folder, Day 1" and roll back over. The school will still be standing when you get back. The kids will survive one day of designing imaginary holidays. And you might actually get to sleep past 4:00 AM.

If you found this helpful, consider forwarding it to a colleague who currently looks like they are powered entirely by caffeine and sheer will.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.