The Student You Secretly Dread (And How to Win Them Over)

There is a specific variety of "Sunday Scaries" that doesn’t come from grading piles or unfinished lesson plans. It comes from looking at the roster, seeing one specific name, and feeling a distinct drop in cortisol levels—or a spike, depending on how the previous Friday went. We are told that teachers should have boundless, unconditional affection for every child who walks through the door. But let’s be real: it is difficult to feel warm and fuzzy about a student who actively dismantles your classroom culture, questions your authority, and perhaps even critiques your footwear choices in front of 25 peers.

This newsletter isn't about how to magically transform that student into a model citizen overnight. It is about how to survive the emotional tax of the "unlovable" student, and the one counter-intuitive psychological hack that turns adversaries into allies.

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor

A big 2026 starts now. True builders use this stretch of time to get ahead, not slow down. Launch your website with AI, publish a stunning newsletter, and start earning more money quickly through the beehiiv Ad Network. Use code BIG30 for 30 percent off your first three months. Start building for 30% off today.

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉 Teacher wins Guinness World Record for working 61 years at the same school

👉Holding students’ attention in digital age begins with trust. Teachers need space to build it

👉Are timed tests too stressful? Guidance warns of negative effects

The "Unlovable" Paradox (It’s Not Just You)

Teaching is professional work performed by human beings. While the job description requires patience, the human nervous system is not actually wired to remain calm when a 12-year-old is essentially roasting you for forty-five minutes straight. When a student is rude, dismissive, or aggressive, the brain’s fight-or-flight response kicks in. It is biological, not a lack of vocational calling. The problem arises when the guilt sets in. Teachers often feel shameful for not liking a difficult student, which leads to overcompensating, which leads to burnout when the student (predictably) rejects the overcompensation.

It is helpful to acknowledge the "Unlovable Paradox." The students who are the hardest to like are almost always the ones who need connection the most. However, because they are terrified of rejection, they proactively push adults away to control the narrative. If they make you dislike them first, they don’t have to worry about you letting them down later. It is a brilliant, albeit exhausting, defense mechanism. Understanding this doesn't make the behavior less annoying, but it does make it less personal.

The "I Need Your Help" Hack

If power struggles were an Olympic sport, difficult students would be gold medalists. They are seeking control. Most discipline strategies involve taking power away (detentions, taking away recess, phone calls home). This usually results in World War III. The alternative is the "I Need Your Help" hack. It sounds like a Jedi mind trick, and honestly, it kind of is. Instead of fighting the student for power, the teacher hands it to them—on a silver platter, but with strings attached.

The move is simple. Pull the student aside before class or during a quiet moment (never in front of an audience). Look them in the eye and say something like, "Hey, I’ve noticed people really listen to you in this class. You have a lot of influence. I actually need your help today. Can you handle [specific task] for me? I need someone I can trust to get this right."

Why This Jedi Mind Trick Works

This strategy works because it validates the student's need for status without requiring them to blow up the lesson to get it. The "Class Clown" or the "Ringleader" usually disrupts class to prove they matter. By making them the "Foreman" or the "Tech Support Lead," you are utilizing their natural charisma. If a kid can lead the entire back row into a mutiny, they absolutely have the leadership skills to lead a line or manage the projector.

You are effectively employing the "Benjamin Franklin Effect." Franklin famously observed that he could win over a rival not by doing a favor for them, but by asking the rival to do a favor for him. When the difficult student performs a helpful task, their brain has to resolve the cognitive dissonance: "I am helping this teacher, therefore, I must not hate this teacher." It breaks the cycle of antagonism and replaces it with a fragile, but workable, partnership.

Anger is Just Armor

There is a quote often attributed to Russell Barkley that hits hard: "The kids who need the most love will ask for it in the most unloving ways." When a student screams, shuts down, or throws a pencil, they are wearing armor. That armor is heavy, ugly, and designed to keep people out. It is protecting a very small, very scared child who likely feels unsafe or unseen in other parts of their life.

When we look at a student and see "disrespect," we respond with punishment. When we look at a student and see "armor," we respond with patience. It shifts the internal narrative from "This kid is giving me a hard time" to "This kid is having a hard time." It doesn't mean allowing bad behavior to slide; boundaries are still necessary. But it changes the energy in the room. You stop fighting the armor and start looking for the chinks in the metal where a little bit of light might get through.

You’ve Got This (Even If It’s Messy)

You do not need to be the teacher from an inspirational Hollywood movie who saves the day with a single speech. You just need to be the consistent adult who refuses to take the bait. The goal isn't to fix everything; the goal is to keep the door open.

Try the "Help Hack" this week. Find the student who raises your blood pressure, find a small job that needs doing, and ask for their assistance. It might not work instantly. They might look at you like you have three heads. But eventually, they might just put down the armor for five minutes. And that counts as a win.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.