Your Teaching Policy Shield

In partnership with

We all know the feeling. It’s Sunday night, and the heart rate spikes just thinking about that one student. You know the one—the walking adrenaline shot who can turn a peaceful reading block into a furniture-rearrangement exercise in under thirty seconds. And what’s the advice usually given? "Just build a relationship." "Show them some grace."

While "vibes" and "grace" are lovely concepts for a greeting card, they are notoriously bad at blocking flying staplers. When a situation in the classroom moves from "challenging" to "untenable," relying on emotional bandwidth is a recipe for burnout. It is time to stop trying to be a saint and start being a bureaucrat. It turns out, the most effective shield against chaos isn't your personality—it's your contract.

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor

What do these names have in common?

• Arnold Schwarzenegger

• Codie Sanchez

• Scott Galloway

• Colin & Samir

• Shaan Puri

• Jay Shetty

They all run their businesses on beehiiv. Newsletters, websites, digital products, and more. beehiiv is the only platform you need to take your content business to the next level.

🚨Limited time offer: Get 30% off your first 3 months on beehiiv. Just use code PLATFORM30 at checkout.

Start building for 30% off today.

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉 Gen Z is the first generation less cognitively capable than their parents but Denmark has a solution

👉 Are librarians the key for teaching AI literacy?

👉 Instagram CEO dismisses idea of social media addiction in landmark trial

The "Nice Teacher" Trap

There is a pervasive myth in education that a "good" teacher is a martyr who absorbs chaos like a sponge and converts it into sunshine. We are conditioned to believe that if we just love a student enough, their behavior will magically align with the social contract. Unfortunately, when safety is at risk, this mindset isn't just naive; it’s dangerous. Admin often relies on this "nice teacher" guilt to avoid dealing with hard discipline, treating your physical and emotional safety as a negotiable line item.

The problem with "letting it slide" in the name of empathy is that it teaches the wrong lesson. It signals that boundaries are suggestions and that safety rules are merely decorative. When we refuse to enforce consequences because we don't want to "ruin the relationship," we aren't actually helping the child. We are gaslighting ourselves into accepting a workplace environment that no other professional would tolerate. An accountant doesn't "show grace" to a client who throws a calculator at them; they call security.

The Contractual Cold-Shoulder

So, how does one pivot from "pushover" to "professional"? Enter the Contractual Cold-Shoulder. This isn't about being cold to the child; it's about being clinically detached regarding the process. When a major safety incident occurs, the instinct is often to "reset" the next day to keep the peace. Resist that urge. Instead, assert the right to a safe workspace. If the Code of Conduct dictates a re-entry meeting or an updated behavioral plan after a suspension or major outburst, insist upon it.

Treat the student handbook like the instruction manual for a complex appliance—because it is. If the manual says, "Step 1: Parent Conference," do not skip to Step 5 just to be nice. By sticking rigidly to the agreed-upon procedures, you remove the emotion from the equation. You aren't being "difficult" or "holding a grudge"; you are simply adhering to the district's own policy. It is remarkably hard for administration to argue with someone who is simply quoting their own rulebook back to them.

Weaponized Documentation (The Paper Trail)

If the contract is your shield, documentation is your sword. But most teachers use it wrong—they use email to vent. "I'm so frustrated with Timmy" is an emotional statement that can be dismissed. "At 10:02 AM, Student X violated Section 4.2 of the Student Handbook by throwing a chair," is a liability statement that demands action. Stop sending "feelings" emails and start sending "evidence" emails.

This is where the "Transparency Rule" kicks in. Never go rogue. Every time you document an incident, CC your union rep and the relevant administrator. Use the magic phrase: "Per our conversation..." followed by a summary of the incident and the specific policy violation. This creates a "Documentation Loop" that is impossible to ignore. When you speak the language of liability, compliance, and specific handbook codes, you stop sounding like a complaining employee and start sounding like a potential legal headache. Amazingly, support tends to materialize quite quickly when that shift happens.

Saving the Other 25

It is easy to feel guilty about being a "stickler." But consider the silent majority: the 25+ other students in the room who are trying to learn while dodging the chaos. Every minute spent managing an unsafe situation "with grace" is a minute stolen from their education. Enforcing the rules isn't "mean" to the disruptive student; it is an act of protection for the rest of the class.

We often forget that students crave structure, even the ones fighting it. By maintaining a classroom that functions as a professional workplace rather than a combat zone, you provide a sense of security for everyone. You are safeguarding the learning environment. You deserve to work in a room where "survival" isn't the primary lesson plan, and your students deserve a teacher who isn't running on cortisol fumes.

You Are Not "Difficult," You Are Professional

Ultimately, standing firm on policy is the ultimate form of self-care. It reminds everyone—including yourself—that you are a professional with rights, not a volunteer with a bottomless well of patience. When you become the most "by-the-book" person in the building, you become untouchable.

So, tonight, pour a glass of something nice (or just a really good tea) and read one section of your contract or employee handbook. You might just find the sentence that saves your sanity this semester. You aren't being a rebel; you're just following the rules.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.