The Art of Wasting Time (Productively)

In partnership with

There is a pervasive myth in education that operates much like a guilt-trip from a personal trainer: if you aren't sweating (or teaching) every single second, you aren't working hard enough. This is the "Bell-to-Bell" mandate—the idea that from the moment the morning announcements end to the second the dismissal bell rings, the air should be filled with rigorous instruction. If a student is breathing without a graphic organizer in front of them, surely learning loss is occurring, right?

But here is the reality check that usually gets skipped in professional development seminars: efficiency is not the same thing as effectiveness. While the schedule treats schools like factories designed to output standardized test scores, the raw material is actually human brains. And human brains, famously, do not like being force-fed algebra immediately after having their heart broken in the hallway during a five-minute passing period. Sometimes, the most rigorous thing a teacher can do is stop teaching.

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor

The Briefing Leaders Rely On.

In a landscape flooded with hype and surface-level reporting, The Daily Upside delivers what business leaders actually need: clear, concise, and actionable intelligence on markets, strategy, and business innovation.

Founded by former bankers and veteran business journalists, it's built for decision-makers — not spectators. From macroeconomic shifts to sector-specific trends, The Daily Upside helps executives stay ahead of what’s shaping their industries.

That’s why over 1 million readers, including C-suite executives and senior decision-makers, start their day with it.

No noise. No jargon. Just business insight that drives results.

Subscribe free today.

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉️ Eye-opening: 7 ways to learn faster and improve your memory - backed by neuroscience.

👉️ Trend alert: Professors are banning laptops in class, and the movement is growing.

👉️ Surprising: An Ivy League psychologist says kids should practice defiance — here’s why.

The Industrial Factory Model vs. Actual Human Beings

Education is full of contradictions. Teachers are told to "build authentic relationships" with 150 different students, but in the same breath, they are told to maximize "time on task" to the point of exhaustion. It’s like being told to train for a marathon but never allowed to stop running to drink water. The expectation is that students should be able to switch from "Gym Class Adrenaline" to "Shakespearean Tragedy" in the time it takes to walk down a flight of stairs.

When we treat the first five minutes of class as a race to the curriculum, we miss the room. Students enter the classroom carrying the invisible baggage of their day—the fight with a parent, the failed biology quiz, the anxiety of the lunchroom. "Bell-to-bell" instruction ignores this reality. It demands that robots download data, rather than inviting humans to engage in a process.

The 15-Minute "Nothing" Experiment

So, what happens when a teacher decides to break the rules? A veteran educator recently shared an experiment where they stopped the "bell-to-bell" grind. For ten years, they had pushed content from minute one. Then, they decided to dedicate the first 10 to 15 minutes of a 90-minute block to… absolutely nothing. well, not nothing. They closed the laptops, put down the markers, and asked a simple question: "What is going on in your lives?"

The results were not "learning loss" or chaos. In end-of-course evaluations, nearly 50% of the students cited that specific 15-minute window as the time they felt most known, cared for, and safe. For many, it was the best part of their day. By "wasting" 15% of the class time, the teacher gained 100% of the students' trust. The remaining 75 minutes became more productive because the students were actually present, rather than just physically occupying a seat while their minds were still in the hallway.

How to "Schedule" Connection (Without Getting Fired)

Now, for the practical part. If an administrator walks in and sees everyone chatting, the instinct is to panic and throw a worksheet at someone. However, this "downtime" can be structured in a way that is defensible, pedagogical, and frankly, life-saving for the classroom culture. If anyone asks, you aren't "chitchatting"; you are conducting "Tier 1 Social-Emotional Check-ins."

Here are a few formats to try that require zero prep but yield high returns:

• Roses and Thorns: Go around the room (or in small groups). One good thing (Rose) and one struggle (Thorn) from the week.

• Happies and Crappies: The rhyme makes it memorable. A quick share of a positive and a negative.

• Pit or Peak: What was the low point (pit) or high point (peak) of the day so far?

• Connection Circles: A designated time where the only rule is that laptops are closed, and we talk about news, stressors, or that weird viral TikTok trend that no one over 30 understands.

Maslow Before Bloom (The ROI of Chitchat)

There is an old educational adage: "Maslow before Bloom." It means you have to address basic human needs (safety, belonging) before you can expect higher-order thinking (analyzing, creating). When teachers skip the connection to get to the content, they are trying to build a penthouse on a foundation made of anxiety and distraction.

Think of that 10 minutes not as a loss, but as an investment. It is the buy-in fee. When students feel that a teacher actually cares about them as people—not just as data points or vessels for essay formatting—they work harder. They misbehave less. They take academic risks because they feel safe. The Return on Investment (ROI) of listening to a student complain about their part-time job for two minutes is often a semester of cooperation.

Permission to Pause

This week, consider this a permission slip to take a breath. The curriculum will still be there in ten minutes. The standardized test will still be a bureaucratic nightmare regardless of whether you start teaching at 8:00 AM or 8:10 AM.

Try one "human check-in" this week. Close the door, ignore the pacing guide for a moment, and just ask them how they are doing. You might be surprised to find that the most valuable lesson taught all week doesn't have a standard attached to it.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.