That "Perfect" Teacher on Instagram is a Lie

It’s 9:30 p.m., the house is finally quiet, and the only light comes from a phone. It’s the late-night social media "doom scroll," but for teachers. And there she is: Ms. Flawless. Her bulletin board looks like it was art-directed by Wes Anderson. Her students are all sitting cross-legged, smiling, and appear to be silently collaborating on a project about... sustainable farming? In second grade? Suddenly, the lesson on fractions that kind of, sort of, mostly worked feels like a dumpster fire. That feeling creeps in—the one that whispers,

"You're a fraud, and any minute now, they're all going to find out."

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉️ The World’s Most Educated Populations, Across 45 Countries

👉️ Teacher wins £140K payout after co-worker said she 'let students down' by taking sick leave for back operation

👉️Use 'Close Reading' to Retain Every Detail When You Study

🔉 But first, a word from today’s sponsor:

The Simplest Way To Create and Launch AI Agents

Imagine if ChatGPT, Zapier, and Webflow all had a baby. That's Lindy.

With Lindy, you can build AI agents and apps in minutes simply by describing what you want in plain English.

From inbound lead qualification to AI-powered customer support and full-blown apps, Lindy has hundreds of agents that are ready to work for you 24/7/365.

Stop doing repetitive tasks manually. Let Lindy automate workflows, save time, and grow your business.

Get $20 Worth of Free Credits

And now, back to our regular scheduled program 👇️ 

The "Perfect Teacher" Is a Performance Art (And You're Backstage)

Let's be clear: that "perfect teacher" is a phantom. They haunt the hallways, the staff room, and especially the #TeacherLife hashtag. It’s the colleague with the laminated, color-coded, 12-point behavior system that actually works. It’s the one whose students never seem to yell "I'M TELLING!" at the top of their lungs during silent reading. Their existence seems to be a personal attack on our own chaotic, messy, beautiful reality.

This comparison game is the root of imposter syndrome. It’s that professional-grade anxiety that convinces us our successes are flukes and our failures are proof of our incompetence. We’re all walking around feeling like we’re the only one faking it, while everyone else seems to have read a secret manual.

Here’s the truth: social media is a highlight reel. It’s performance art. It doesn't show the 14 takes it took to get that "perfect" classroom video. It doesn't show the moment the laminator jammed, the lesson that bombed, or the snack time that devolved into a heated debate over who really discovered Goldfish crackers. You’re not seeing the reality; you're seeing the final, edited cut. And you're comparing their highlight reel to your behind-the-scenes bloopers.

The Antidote: Your Private "Real-Win Reel"

If the public highlight reel is the poison, the "Real-Win Reel" is the antidote. This is the practical, 30-second habit that can rewire the "I'm a failure" circuit. It’s a private collection of your actual, non-laminated, often-messy victories. The goal is to celebrate the small, authentic moments that never make it to Instagram because they aren’t visually stunning, but are the actual heart of teaching.

Here’s how it works: Get a sticky note, the back of a gas receipt, or a notes app on your phone. At the end of the day, before packing up, write down one real win. That’s it. No one else ever needs to see it.

What counts as a "real win"? It's not "achieved 100% mastery on Standard 4.NBT.B.5." It’s "That quiet kid in the back smiled at my terrible dad joke." It’s "We only had one meltdown during the math lesson, not the usual three." It's "I remembered to drink water before 2 p.m." or "Alex, who hasn't spoken all week, finally asked a question." These small wins are the proof that you're not a fraud. You're a human making a human connections.

Find Your "Failure Friday" Crew

Perfection is isolating. No one wants to sit at the lunch table with Ms. Flawless because it’s intimidating. Imperfection, on the other hand, is a magnet for connection. Imposter syndrome thrives in silence, so the second step is to break that silence—but not by sharing your "wins." Share your "fails."

Find one or two trusted colleagues—the ones who will also admit their classroom smells vaguely of lost gym socks. Create a "Failure Friday" pact. This can be a text chain, a five-minute chat by the (always broken) copy machine, or a shared beverage after the final bell. The only rule is to share one glorious, spectacular, or just plain clumsy failure from the week.

"My entire lesson on metaphors crashed and burned." "I called a student by their sibling's name... a sibling I taught three years ago." "My 'calm-down corner' accidentally became the 'get-even-more-hyped-up corner.'" Sharing these moments does two things: It proves you’re not alone, and it gives everyone permission to be human. It’s hard to feel like an imposter when you realize everyone else is also just winging it with style.

Why Students Need a Human, Not a Hero

Here is the most important part, the thing to write on the mirror: Students do not need a perfect teacher. They need a human one. They are not connecting with the flawless bulletin board. They are connecting with you.

Think about it. The most powerful lessons in resilience, problem-solving, and emotional intelligence don't come from a perfect worksheet. They come from watching a real adult navigate a real struggle. When a lesson plan implodes and the teacher says, "Wow, that did not work at all. Let's try something else," they are modeling flexibility. When a teacher makes a mistake and says, "I got that wrong. I'm sorry. Let's fix it together," they are modeling accountability and humility.

A classroom run by a "perfect" robot is sterile. A classroom run by a passionate, trying, sometimes-frazzled human is a place where students learn it’s safe to try, safe to fail, and safe to be themselves. They see you mess up and recover, and it gives them the courage to do the same.

Your humanity is not your greatest weakness; it is your single greatest teaching tool. The kids don't remember the curriculum details 20 years from now. They remember the teacher who made them feel safe, seen, and genuinely liked—flaws and all. They remember the human.

Ditch the Cape

You are not an imposter. You are a person doing an impossibly complex, emotionally demanding, and critically important job in a world that gives you very few resources to do it. The feeling of "faking it" isn't a sign of your inadequacy; it's a sign that you care enough to worry about it.

So, this week, ditch the invisible superhero cape. It's heavy, it's fake, and it's probably a tripping hazard. The challenge is simple: Collect one "real win" for your private reel. And if you're feeling brave, find a colleague and share one "real fail."

You've got this.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.