Tactical Surrender; A guide

Every educator has encountered the "Energy Vampire." This is the student who treats your meticulously planned lesson on the Magna Carta as their personal opening-mic night at the Apollo. They aren't just disruptive; they are performing. They are waiting for you to play your part in the script: the sigh, the "I’ll wait," the stern walk toward their desk. It’s a choreographed dance of frustration that leaves you drained and them energized by the spotlight.

The traditional advice usually involves "building a stronger relationship," which is often code for "spend your lunch break trying to convince a teenager that being a YouTube prankster isn't a viable 401(k) strategy." But there is a more efficient, subtractive truth available to the exhausted professional. Sometimes, the most radical thing a teacher can do is absolutely nothing.

🚀 Noteworthy News

👉 The Most Prevalent Disability in the Classroom may be FASD - and Supporting Students Is Vital

👉 Instragram and Youtube Owners Built ‘Addiction Machines’, trial told

👉 High School Grades are on the Rise

The Myth of the Infinite Emotional Reservoir

In the world of toxic positivity, teachers are expected to be bottomless wells of patience and grace. We are told that every outburst is a "cry for help" or a "mismatched learning style." While empathy is the backbone of the profession, treating every minor disruption as a high-stakes psychological intervention is a one-way ticket to burnout city—population: you, and a very cold cup of coffee.

When we constantly redirect, we are actually rewarding the behavior. To an attention-seeker, a reprimand is still an interaction. It’s "The Teacher Show," starring them as the guest of honor. Every time we engage in a power struggle, we validate the disruptor's belief that they are the center of the classroom universe. It’s time to stop being the co-star in their drama and start being the audience member who just walked out for a snack.

Deploying the Vacuum: The Tactical Step-Back

The "Tactical Step-Back" is a zero-budget, high-impact maneuver designed for the purely attention-seeking disruption. When the student starts their routine—be it animal noises, seat-assignment debates, or a sudden fascination with the ceiling—you simply stop. You don't get angry; you get boring. You look at your notes, you check the weather out the window, or you study a particularly interesting speck of dust on the chalkboard.

By removing yourself from the equation, you create a social vacuum. You aren't "giving up"; you are implementing planned ignoring on steroids. Without your reaction to push against, the student's behavior loses its structural integrity. They are a performer on a stage with the house lights turned off and the sound system unplugged. It is awkward, it is quiet, and it is exactly what needs to happen.

Let the Cavalry Lead the Charge

Nature abhors a vacuum, and teenagers abhor an annoying classmate who is currently the only thing standing between them and the end of the period. This is where the magic happens. When you refuse to be the enforcer, the "quiet majority" of the class—the students who actually want to finish their work so they can go to soccer practice—will eventually lose their patience.

Wait for the inevitable. It usually starts with a heavy sigh from the back row, followed by a "Bro, shut up," or a "You’re literally embarrassing yourself, stop." A peer’s judgment carries a social weight that no detention slip can match. Once the disruptor is shamed into silence by their own ecosystem, employ the "Amnesia Technique." Pick up your sentence exactly where you left off. No "Thank you, Class," no "I appreciate the silence." Just immediate, seamless instruction.

The Reluctant Zen of Modern Teaching

There is a profound ego check in realizing that a group of annoyed 15-year-olds has more behavioral leverage than a person with a Master’s degree. But leaning into that reality is incredibly liberating. It acknowledges that you are a facilitator of learning, not a prison warden or a lion tamer. When you relinquish the need to micromanage every micro-behavior, you save your emotional energy for the students who are actually there to engage.

Trusting the classroom's natural social order reminds us that most kids aren't looking for chaos; they’re looking for a functional environment. By stepping back, you aren't abdicating your authority—you're strategically deploying it. You’re letting the disruptor know that their performance isn't worth your time, and you're letting the rest of the class know that you trust them to help maintain the space.

Read the Room: A Critical Caveat

This strategy is strictly for the "class clown" performance, never for students with identified needs requiring specific behavioral support plans. Ignoring a student in genuine crisis is dangerous and likely breaks professional protocols. The goal isn't exclusion; it’s allowing natural social consequences for rudeness to occur—a vital real-world lesson for future employment and interactions. We teach social skills alongside curriculum. As with any strategy, your mileage may vary; you know your students best.

Your Homework: Do Less

This Monday, we challenge you to try one "Tactical Step-Back." When the inevitable distraction occurs, resist the urge to lecture or redirect. Just stop. Let the silence stretch until it becomes physically uncomfortable for everyone involved. Let the "Cavalry" do what they do best.

Remember, you aren't being "lazy"—you're being efficient. Your sanity is a finite resource; spend it on the students who are hungry to learn, not the ones who are just hungry for a reaction. You’ve got this. Or rather, your students have this.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.