I Don't Love Kids. I'm Still a Good Teacher.

There is a sentence that, if said aloud in a staff room, will cause a colleague to slowly lower their yogurt and reassess the whole relationship. It is not a slur. It is not about administration. It is five words long, and it is time somebody said it kindly, in a well-lit room, with snacks.

🔉 But first, this week's sponsor is for teachers running a side project, small business, or online shop.

Stop Paying for 6 Tools. One AI Does It All.

Most e-commerce sellers juggle 6–8 tools and pay hundreds monthly to keep operations running. StoreClaw replaces the stack with one autonomous AI engine that monitors competitors, optimizes listings, automates marketing, and tracks profit 24/7. Connect your store and let AI handle the work — no prompts, no complex setup, no credit card required.

Try if for free today

And now back to making you an even better teacher. ⬇️ 

Noteworthy News

The Sentence Nobody Says in the Staff Room

The sentence is: I don't actually love kids.

Say it and watch a room decide, in real time, that it is dealing with a monster. And yet there exists a whole quiet population of genuinely excellent teachers; the ones whose students orbit them at recess, whose data is solid, who arrive at year fifteen still curious about something, who would tell you privately that loving kids was never the engine.

They care about their students with a ferocity that would frankly alarm HR. They will fight a district over a reading assessment. They remember which kid's grandmother is sick. But love kids, as a category, in the way one loves golden retrievers or a well-organized fridge? Not really.

What they love is the learning — the click of a thing being understood, the moment a nine-year-old's entire face reorganizes because place value has finally landed.

This is the part that rarely gets said out loud: that second thing may be the more durable fuel.

The profession has quietly made warmth the price of admission and treated content passion as optional garnish - a sprig of parsley on the side of the plate. Which is exactly backwards, and it is precisely why the field tolerates an elementary teacher announcing "I'm not a math person" as though it were a charming quirk, like disliking cilantro, rather than a professional emergency happening in front of thirty witnesses who are all taking notes.

Nobody is arguing against warmth here. Warmth is lovely. Warmth is why the good ones get birthday cards a decade later. The argument is narrower and stranger than that: the teachers who came for the learning are not lesser teachers. They may, quietly, be running on the better fuel.

Loving Kids Gets You Through the Cute Parts. Loving Learning Gets You Through Fractions in February.

Affection is a finite resource. This is not a moral failing; it is inventory. Affection is abundant in September, when the pencils are sharp and the class list is still a list of strangers with good handwriting. It thins by Thursday. It thins considerably at 8:05 a.m. on the morning after a student has bitten someone, when the professional expectation is to feel warmly toward that student, on schedule, on demand, with a smile.

Curiosity does not work that way. Curiosity does not check whether the student was adorable yesterday. It does not require the room to be grateful. It is renewable in the way that a good question is renewable — asked, partially answered, and immediately generating three more. A teacher running on curiosity has an internal supply line that does not depend on the weather, the moon, or the behaviour of an eight-year-old named Braxton.

Consider what this means for longevity. Burnout narratives tend to focus on workload, and fairly so. But there is a second, quieter drain: an entire professional identity constructed on affection, which then acts surprised when affection runs out. It was always going to run out. It is a candle, not a furnace.

The teachers still standing at year twenty are frequently the ones who found something inside the content that keeps giving; a stubborn fascination with why kids conflate area and perimeter, an ongoing feud with the passive voice, a genuine desire to know what happens if the experiment is run at a different temperature.

The Cold Solve — Ten Minutes, No Laminating

Here is the habit. It takes ten minutes, costs nothing, and requires zero scalloped borders.

Step one: pull tomorrow's student work. The problem set, the passage, the exit ticket — whatever the kids will actually touch with their actual hands.

Step two: do it. Cold. No teacher's edition. No answer key open in a second tab "just in case." Work it like a student, on paper, start to finish.

Step three: mark the flinches. Every place of hesitation, every second-guess, every itch to peek at the key — circle it. No judgment, no self-flagellation, just a circle.

Step four: those circles are the lesson plan. With genuinely eerie accuracy, they mark the exact places students will get stuck. Not because the teacher is deficient, but because the problem has a hinge there — and it just got found.

Step five: fix one. Ask the teacher next door. Watch a four-minute video. One circle, one fix, close the laptop, go home.

The crucial part, and the part that makes this survivable: this replaces prep, it does not add to it. 

This is a subtractive trade. Skip the anchor chart. Skip the color-coded bins. Skip the bulletin board letters that took forty minutes and will be taken down in three weeks. No child's understanding of regrouping has ever hinged on a scalloped border. Not one. There is no research base for scalloped borders and there never will be.

And notice what ten minutes of this does to a person. For the length of one cold problem set, a teacher stops being the warm adult at the front and becomes the learner in the room. That is the muscle. That is, honestly, the whole thing.

The Adult Who Stays in the Room

There is a strange mercy hidden inside the Cold Solve, which is that it grants permission to be a person who does not know things — on purpose, in private, for ten minutes a day.

That permission is rarer than it should be in a profession where the adult is expected to arrive pre-loaded with every answer, like a vending machine that also does yard duty.

And that permission is, as it happens, the exact thing students most need modeled. An adult who meets something hard, gets stuck, feels the specific and unglamorous discomfort of not knowing, and stays in the room anyway. Every kid in every class is trying to learn how to do that. Most of them will never see it demonstrated by a grown-up.

And it cannot be faked. A teacher cannot model intellectual courage in a subject they are quietly fleeing. The students know. They always know. The "I'm not a math person" line lands on a room full of children who are, at that precise moment, being told that math is a thing certain people simply are — and that if it feels hard, they must not be one of them.

The alternative is available tomorrow, for ten minutes, with a pencil.

Permission Slip

So: care deeply about the students. Be relentless about their success. Fight the district when the district needs fighting. None of that is on the table here.

But if the thing that actually gets a teacher out of bed is the process of understanding something (the click, the hinge, the reorganizing face) that is not a character flaw requiring a quiet apology in the staff room. That is the good stuff. That is the part that lasts.

Try one Cold Solve this week. Ten minutes, tomorrow's worksheet, no answer key. Then hit reply and tell us what you circled — the sticking points found this way tend to be weirdly universal, and we would love to run a few.

WHAT DO YOU THINK?

We would LOVE to hear from you!

Reply to this email, or send us a message on Instagram! We’re here to walk with you in these crazy times!

Part of what makes The PEN Weekly community so special is the fact that our readers are teachers from around the world! We’re not going to lie, we think that’s pretty darn cool!

We’ll see you again on Wednesday 🍎

Share this newsletter!

Do you know someone who would appreciate reading the PEN? Share this newsletter with them! Our goal is to reach as many teachers as possible, and to build a community of teachers supporting teachers.